image


image

The Librarian of Forgotten Endings

Shreya
FANTASY
Report this story
Found something off? Report this story for review.

Submitted to Contest #3 in response to the prompt: 'Write a story about life after a "happily ever after"'

Once upon a time—but not in the way you expect—there was a woman named Elara who lived in the city’s quietest corner, where the buildings seemed to hush themselves and even the streetlamps blinked less frequently.

Elara was the head librarian at the Library of Forgotten Stories, an old domed building made of black stone and foggy windows. Unlike other libraries, this one didn’t store bestsellers or biographies. Instead, it housed stories people had once begun but never finished—unfinished novels, torn-out diary entries, scribbled love letters, whispered lullabies, and dreams people dared not pursue.

Each forgotten story lived in a glass jar, labeled not by title, but by emotion: Regret, Joy, Longing, Fear, Almost. Thousands of jars lined the shelves in glowing rows, humming with words that had never reached an ending.

Elara, soft-spoken and nearly always in gray, had been the librarian since the age of seventeen. She never questioned how she got the job. One day, a letter had appeared under her pillow with the library’s key and the message:

"You're the only one who remembers how stories are supposed to end."

And so, for twenty years, she had tended to the stories—dusting the jars, murmuring half-finished sentences, sometimes even trying to guess the endings aloud, though the jars never responded.

Until the day one did.

It was a Wednesday.

Elara was closing early due to a leak in the dome. She’d already locked the main doors when she noticed one of the jars glowing more brightly than usual. Happily Ever After, the label read—odd, because no story had ever been sealed with that emotion. Most stories about happiness were either Hopeful or Incomplete.

She approached slowly. Inside the jar was a single sentence:

"She knew the stranger in the garden was here to change everything."

Elara frowned. “That’s... familiar.”

The jar pulsed, as if in response.

She reached out and touched the glass.

The world dissolved.

She blinked—and found herself standing in a lush green garden she didn’t recognize, barefoot, holding a basket of sun-warmed peaches.

Birdsong played softly through the air. And sitting on the bench ahead was a man she couldn’t name—but her heart recognized him like a favorite melody.

“Elara,” he said, smiling, “I was starting to think you wouldn’t come back.”

Her breath caught.

“Back?”

He rose, and walked toward her with that calm confidence of someone who had waited many lifetimes. “We were writing a story, remember? But you stopped. You got scared.”

And suddenly, she did remember.

Not just the garden.

Not just him.

But an entire life—one where she had left the Library, chosen love, lived boldly, wrote furiously, laughed often. A life she had begun writing in her journal years ago, a ‘fictional’ version of herself who dared more than she did.

“I thought it was just a dream,” she whispered.

He took her hand. “Most true things begin that way.”

Over the days—weeks?—that followed, Elara lived the life she had once only imagined. They rebuilt a small house together on the edge of the woods. She spent mornings writing, afternoons painting the walls in ridiculous colors, and evenings wrapped in his arms watching stars she never thought she'd touch.

For the first time in forever, she forgot to feel afraid.

And when the time came—when he knelt under the same peach tree and asked, “Will you write the rest of our story with me?”—she said yes without hesitation.

This was it. This was her happily ever after.

Until she woke up.

Back in the Library.

The jar now read: "Almost."

“No, no, no,” she gasped. “It was real—it was real!”

She yanked the jar off the shelf. Inside, the sentence now read:
“And then she chose to forget.”

Elara spent weeks trying to return to the garden.

She touched every glowing jar, whispered every phrase, begged the shelves. But the world refused to change. The dream—or whatever it had been—was gone.

She almost gave up.

Until one evening, while organizing the Hopeful section, she found another jar. Faintly glowing. Unlabeled.

Inside, one line:

"He waited, even when he no longer remembered what for."

And next to it, another:

"She came back, not to finish the story, but to rewrite it."

Elara stood there a long time.

Then she grabbed a pen.

She began visiting the jars one by one, whispering not the endings people had intended, but the ones they needed.

— A letter labeled Fear became a message of reconciliation.
— A diary under Guilt transformed into forgiveness.
— A scribbled novel marked Abandonment now ended in redemption.

Every time she rewrote a story, the jar’s label changed to Healing.

And every time she gave someone else a new ending, she felt a little closer to hers.

One stormy night, decades later, a girl with rain in her hair knocked on the Library’s door.

She was holding a jar.

“I think this belongs here,” she said. “I found it in my mother’s attic. It has your name on it.”

Elara took the jar with shaking hands. She hadn't seen her own name in a long time.

Inside, one final sentence:

"She finally stopped being the keeper of other endings and allowed herself her own."

She smiled.

Closed the library.

And walked into the rain.

Years passed.

The Library of Forgotten Stories still stands, but no one knows who runs it now. The shelves are different. Brighter. Full of jars labeled Bravery, Discovery, Belonging.

And in the very center, under a skylight always filled with sun, is a single jar sealed with gold:

“Happily Ever After.”

Inside, a sentence loops endlessly, glowing softly:

“She lived the story she once only dared to dream

Share this story
image
LET'S TALK image
User profile
Author of the Story
Thank you for reading my story! I'd love to hear your thoughts
User profile
(Minimum 30 characters)

50 points given❤ keep showing your love to my story The Devil\'s Plan ❤

0 reactions
React React
👍 ❤️ 👏 💡 🎉

I awarded this story 50 points please check out my story . You should check it out! https://notionpress.com/write_contest/details/4037/the-knock-at-midnight-

👍 1 reactions
React React
👍 ❤️ 👏 💡 🎉

HI SHREYA your story is very impressive so I have awarded 50 points please write more story like this

0 reactions
React React
👍 ❤️ 👏 💡 🎉

Hi Shreya, your story is very intersting I have awarded 50 points

0 reactions
React React
👍 ❤️ 👏 💡 🎉

Hi Shreya, Your story is very impressive; I have awarded 50 points. Success depends not only on how well you have written your story, but also on how many have read the story and commented. Please read, comment and award 50 points to my story ‘Assalamualaikum’. Please go to the url of the internet browser that displays your story; it is in the form https://notionpress.com/write_contest/details/nnnn, where nnnn is the sequence number of your story. Please replace nnnn by 2294; the url will be https://notionpress.com/write_contest/details/2294; please hit enter; you will get my story ‘Assalamualaikum’. Please login using your notion press id; award 50 points and comment.

👍 1 reactions
React React
👍 ❤️ 👏 💡 🎉